I caught up with my colleague at the Ethics and Pubic Policy Center, Nathanael Blake, to talk about his new book, Victims of the Revolution: How Sexual Liberation Hurts Us All (Ignatius Press, 2025).
In addition to being a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, Nathanael Blake is a regular columnist for The Federalist, World Opinions, and other popular publications. He received his doctorate from the Catholic University of America. He lives in Virginia with his wife and children.
TOH: What was the motivation behind this book?
Blake: It is time for Christian conservatives to rise from our defensive crouch. Though the sexual revolution won, bitter experience is now revealing that its promises were lies. A culture of sexual liberation has left Americans, on average, lonelier and unhappier—and even having less, and less satisfying sex. I think that people are ready to examine how things came to this, and to look for a better way to live. Victims of the Revolution argues that a Christian understanding of sexuality and the human person can both explain what went wrong and how we can begin to set things right. It thereby unites many of the subjects and themes I’ve been writing on in recent years in an effort to encourage and equip Christians to confront the relational and culture catastrophes that resulted from sexual liberation. Christians sexual morality is not killjoy scolding or hateful bigotry, but a protector and promotor of real human flourishing rooted in fundamental truths about human nature and how we thrive and are fulfilled.
The work of writing the book got going when my family was visiting Ryan Anderson’s farm one winter evening. I had discussed the general idea with a few people, including my wife and Carl Olson of Catholic World Report; talking with Ryan took it from a vague outline in my head to something I had to put down on paper (well, pixels, anyway).
TOH: What do you think its real strength is, particularly since there are other books out there that deal with the sexual revolution?
Blake: Victims of the Revolution stands out as a current and comprehensive account of how and why the sexual revolution failed, and why Christian sexual morals are better for us, both individually and as a society. I think that combination is unique.
The sexual revolution is an evolving and moving target, and each manifestation is destructive in distinct ways. For example, a decade ago gender ideology was a fringe issue, now it is at the center of our political and cultural debates. Keeping up with the shifting manifestations of the sexual revolution is an important part of effectively critiquing it.
The evolving nature of the sexual revolution makes it important for critics to be comprehensive. That is, though it would be tedious to chronicle every aspect of the sexual revolution and its history, it is important to identify the false anthropology that unifies the sexual revolution across its iterations, and which results in its various evil consequences. This allows for a contrast between the sexual revolution’s false promises and the protective and nurturing truths of the Christian understanding of sex, marriage and family.
These last points are where some of the better secular critiques of the sexual revolution, such as the work of Mary Harrington and Louise Perry, fell short. For all of their insights, they were unable or unwilling to level a comprehensive critique at the sexual revolution, or to offer a grounded vision of a better way to live.
TOH: Who are some of the victims of the sexual revolution that you think most people miss or don't think about as victims?
Blake: Pour one out for the “childless cat ladies.” Much of the online Right, and even the current Vice President, has dismissed single women as Prozac-popping liberal harpies who would be happier if they had settled down to a family rather than a career. But with whom were they supposed to settle down when so many men are porn-addled, underachieving, irresponsible, and allergic to commitment?
Young women are doing well in terms of educational and career achievements, but they are increasingly unhappy and mentally unwell. And no wonder when even the left-wing Guardian is now worried about “the rapid rise and horrifying risks of choking during sex,” and wondering “How has this extreme practice been normalized?” The answer is that the sexual revolution has poisoned the relational well and created a sexual wasteland, and women may be suffering the most from this. The sexual revolution and the feminists who embraced it didn’t abolish sexism, they just redirected it into new, sometimes worse, channels. Instead of being loved and cherished as women, women today are expected to thrive while modeling themselves on caddish (to use an old word) and careerist men. But this doesn’t work, especially when men are being encouraged to prioritize their own selfish desires.
TOH: If you could tweak one thing in the culture back in the early days of the Sexual Revolution, what would it be to protect against its greatest harm?
Blake: I would wish for more respect for human life in utero. The primary reason, of course, is the lives that would have been saved had abortion not reigned unchecked for half a century. But there would be other benefits because, as a couple of our colleagues have explained, abortion harms everything and solves nothing. Abortion further entrenches the very evils that abortion is supposed to fix. Abortion creates a crueler culture in which men, women, and children are driven further apart and set against each other. Instead of a fundamental solidarity between mother, father, and child, there is a bloody battleground of competing interests, with the weakest violently eliminated.
TOH: What do you think is the way forward for Christians?
Blake: The broken promises of the sexual revolution give us an opportunity to show that a better way of life is possible. In a selfish, cynical world filled with exploitation, the joyful self-giving and loving commitment of Christian marriage and family life will stand out. We are made for love, and most of us called to experience it through the vocations of marriage and family, which are nourished and protected by God’s law as it directs us toward our good and that of those around us.
Churches must deliberately work to form men and women for the vocations of marriage and family life, to bring them together, and to help them sustain and strengthen their families. This is countercultural now; it cannot be presumed to happen automatically, without the aid and accountability that the church can provide.
Though following Christian sexual morality avoids the pitfalls and self-inflicted wounds of sin, we will still endure trials and troubles in this life. Even our marriage vows contain an intrinsic heartbreak, as till death do us part means one spouse mourning at the grave of the other. Amidst the inevitable suffering of life, which may be intensified by the vulnerability of love, Christianity provides comfort and sanctifies our sorrows. And it teaches us that how we are to live now also points us to how we are meant to be fulfilled in eternity, for marriage is an image of Christ and the Church.


